I believe this data and subject could be debated all day long and never get agreed upon. I don't have a problem with the slot limit but to me those r the best fish to eat. The 18-24" fish... I would have to agree with the idea of if u take out some of the fish the fish that are left have a better chance to find food and be healthier without the competition of that many more fish... I guess it's like deer hunting take out deer from the herd to keep the herd healthy... Either way I'm with dreamcatcher this issue is above my pay grade ill stick to catching fish and abiding to the rules.