I've been using the solunar charts for probably 20 yrs for hunting and fishing.Sometimes good or poor fishing coincides but it's highly variable.Alot of other factors influence the bite besides moon position.I do check my tables every time I do hunt or fish but I don't let those tables interfere with a day fishing.Weather has a much greater influence on fishing than the solunar tables.When it comes to deer hunting,I do plan many of my hunts on those tables.And several of my best bucks have been taken at peak activity phases.But I would rather fish at first light than wait for a midday activity phase.Good luck and thanks for the detailed report.