You are not the only one, we tried Sunday and Monday with basically the same results you mentioned. On Sunday we did get 4 keepers, two 18" and two 20", which gave us hope for Monday. Monday we worked hard for 5 hours and had a great time in the lake, really enjoyed the boat and beautiful weather but no keeper walleye. We did catch our share of white bass and others but that was it. It seems like everyone around us was trolling, I just can't bring myself to do that yet. We were working the area between Kelley's and Put-In-Bay both days, marking a ton of fish but they did not like our presentation of worm harnesses or anything else I could find in the boat to try. Maybe next time.