That's exactly how my crew reacts to fishing after a afternoon at Cabana Sams partying with fishkiller,
Actually it usually goes this way when were watching poles:
Was that a hit?
I don't know I didn't see it?
Look It might be a fish?
Reel it in?
Does it feel like a fish?
Yeah -I think so?
No - it's gone?
Wait - it might be there?
Now it feels light?
It's still there?
I feel head shakes?
There's something on top of the water?
Keep reeling - I'll get the net.
It looks white?
Never mind the net - It's a sheap head
Let's check the bait on the other poles?
Yeah go a head YOU check the bait?

But it's fun - ain't it guys?
then you hear that Bailey & Fishkiller have 2 in the box and you have 6?