The winner by unaminous decision is CRANE CREEK. I fish brest bay till the ice is safe in Ohio. I live in Temperance and prefer to fish where the fish are. We are driving our ATV's 4.0 miles out over 7" of ice. I sit on my ATV while I fish. You have to try Crane Creek/ Metzgers/ Camp Perry/ Cawtaba. That's where the reefs they spawn on are. There are trails like highways to follow and you'll see shanty towns as you go. My advise is go early and stay away from the pack. They just like company and make too much noise. We are fishing from anywhere between 18' and 24' fow. Open water is 5 miles out.

Good Luck and Good Fishing