James, No doubt the fish off Cawtaba seem to run larger. We seem to catch more fish off Magee Marsh vs. Cawtaba SP. It's a personal preference. If I gave a fillet off a 10lb walleye to a friend in Toledo. They would ask " What the heck did I do"? Us locals, whom fish on a regular basis prefer the 18"-22" walleye for the table. Yeah, catching the big ones is allot of fun and fulfills the adrenelien rush, but I have 4 on the wall over 32" and the wife wont let me mount anothe walleye. If I did it would be the last thing I mounted for a while. Anywho. We are catching nice catches and we'll leave the the migrating brood stock for you.

Good Luck and Good Fishing, keep some around for our grandchildren