Harnesses catch the most fish. And stickbaits catch the biggest from my personal experience. Colors vary. Riggers, dipsys, jets, torpedoes, and leadcore. Are just about nessesities when the eyes suspend and head to deeper water. Buffalo water is good now. Watch this thread for reports. Once the lake warms up. The fish head west to deeper water. Then sp and down are better.
Night trolling the outer breakwalls usually produce smaller eyes all summer. You'll almost always see boats trolling there every night weather permitting. Get yourself a good topo map of the eastern lake. One with GPS cords on it for stuff like Seneca, waverly, Woodlawn are better yet. Great bunch of guys on this board. Lots of info shared between us. Plus we're all pretty much local so it's nice to meet up with each other. This is one of the better forums I belong to. Definatly the funnest and most easy going. Ill post my report if I get out tomorrow. I'd love to blow off work and go all day. But can't afford it right now. Damn I hate being a slave to the man!!!!